One year after Omar Khan's blockbuster trade, the Pittsburgh Steelers are reeling from the consequences of their decision to trade Minkah Fitzpatrick for Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith. The trade, which seemed like a strategic move at the time, has now been deemed a disaster by many analysts. The early returns are not great, and the Steelers are paying a high price for their mistake.
The trade terms were as follows: Pittsburgh received Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith, while Miami received Minkah Fitzpatrick and a 2027 fifth-round pick. The decision to part ways with Fitzpatrick was understandable, as the Dolphins were undergoing a rebuild and needed to clear salary cap space. However, the Steelers' decision to trade for Smith was more questionable.
Smith had one of the least efficient seasons from a tight end in NFL history, and his poor individual stats were a significant issue. At an APY of over $12 million, the Steelers were better off cutting ties with him. The opportunity cost of keeping Smith was high, as it prevented the team from utilizing Pat Freiermuth effectively.
The trade also involved a late-round pick swap, which is often overlooked. Giving up a 2027 fifth-round pick is unfortunate for the Steelers, especially considering the depth and talent of the 2027 draft class.
One thing that stands out is the comparison between Fitzpatrick and Ramsey. Despite playing different positions, their stat lines were almost identical. Fitzpatrick had 82 total tackles, four TFL, a sack, six passes defensed, an INT, and a forced fumble in 14 games. Ramsey, on the other hand, had 88 total tackles, four TFL, three sacks, eight passes defensed, and an INT in 17 games. This comparison highlights the value of Fitzpatrick, who delivered comparable production to Ramsey.
The trade has been labeled as a demerit on Omar Khan's track record as Pittsburgh's GM. The story hasn't been fully written yet, but Ramsey's new role as a STAR defensive back in Pittsburgh's new system could unlock his potential. The defensive staff has already identified him as a key player to 'weaponize' this season, with late-career Charles Woodson as a template.
In conclusion, the trade has not aged well, and the Steelers are paying a high price for their mistake. The future of the trade remains uncertain, but anything short of a strong season from Ramsey will likely be seen as a firm demerit on Khan's leadership.
